DominikM Posted September 2, 2008 Posted September 2, 2008 Hello ! I am creating my AVCHD DVD disks by dumping data from Data Card to HDD using HD Writer software and than burning dvd in UDF 2.5 using ImgBurn. The latest version of the latter creates however additional 'CERTIFICATE' folder which is correct for BD disks but not for AVCHD. Power DVD 8 simply refuses to play them. So there should not be such folder in AVCHD disk. Is there any way to disable that feature (creation of 'CERTIFICATE' folder) thanks for your answers. Dominik
LIGHTNING UK! Posted September 2, 2008 Posted September 2, 2008 It's actually joined on to the 'create AUDIO_TS folder' option for DVD. Do you have any info that might help me tell the difference between an AVCHD disc and a BD disc? (like other file/folder differences) EDIT: Are you 100% sure it's the 'certificate' folder that's causing the problem? All the burning guides I've seen for AVCHD have specifically mentioned adding the 'CERTIFICATE' and 'BDMV' folders to the list of things to burn. I guess you'll find out for sure when you disable automatic creation of the certificate folder via that option I mentioned and test it
DominikM Posted September 3, 2008 Author Posted September 3, 2008 I noticed it when I tried to play AVCHD disc burn using new version of ImgBurn. PowerDVD simply stated 'unknown disc format' when there was 'CERTIFICATE' folder and everything went ok when the folder was absent. The AVCHD dvd disc can be also created inside HD Writer from Panasonic and there is no CERTIFICATE folder. AVCHD disc structure is derived from BD and I think that adding CERTIFICATE folder is some kind of workaround to play AVCHD disk on players that does not support AVCHD, in other words to fool them that they are playing BD disc. I am not at home at the moment but I will list directory structures of playable and unplayable AVCHD discs during weekend (on Sunday I think) regards !
nwg Posted September 9, 2008 Posted September 9, 2008 (edited) I am glad to see this thread. I have been having problems with getting AVCHD working in a Samsung BDP 1500 player which does AVCHD. For two weeks I have been getting no disc errors. I checked a AVCHD disc that I borrowed and it didn't have certificate folder. It worked ! I then reburned my disc using Moviefactory and just the BDMV folder. That also worked. So, it does seem that the certificate folder is causing a problem. I am getting a Sony S350 soon and that also does AVCHD. I will try both ways using that as well. Edited September 9, 2008 by nwg
LIGHTNING UK! Posted September 9, 2008 Posted September 9, 2008 I've separated this out now so the AUDIO_TS option can be left enabled and the new CERTIFICATE one can be disabled for those of you just building AVCHD discs.
blutach Posted September 9, 2008 Posted September 9, 2008 FWIW - the wiki on AVC HD shows no certificate folder in the structure. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AVCHD#Overview Regards
nwg Posted September 10, 2008 Posted September 10, 2008 FWIW - the wiki on AVC HD shows no certificate folder in the structure. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AVCHD#Overview Regards I never thought of using Wiki to look at what it said about AVCHD. That would have saved me a couple weeks of messing about. I have had 1080i mpeg 2 material working in the Samsung BD player. My first test was 1080p24 AVC/H264 and the certificate folder which didn't work. I am waiting to do another test without the certificate folder as I originally thought it didn't work with the progressive or 24fps. That site saids it is. I can't believe the solution would be so simple.
blutach Posted September 12, 2008 Posted September 12, 2008 Hi nwg, Doesn't mean the wiki's right, of course. But it's a start! Best to download a copy of the specs and read thru them. Regards
nwg Posted September 13, 2008 Posted September 13, 2008 Is it possible for me to burn without the certificate folder? I tried moviefactory again and came up with no disc despite no certificate folder. I am not convinced that the MF burning program is that good.
mmalves Posted September 13, 2008 Posted September 13, 2008 Go to Tools -> Settings -> Build tab, untick Create AUDIO_TS Folder and hit OK (creation of CERTIFICATE folder is linked to this option in ImgBurn 2.4.2.0) The "No Disc" message sort of gives away that the player was unable to read data from the disc and not the presence or not of the CERTIFICATE folder (I think it would say something like "Invalid Disc/Format"). What brand and type of media you're using? Do you verify your burns? If it's BD-R/BD-RE, do you have FastWrite disabled or enabled?
nwg Posted September 13, 2008 Posted September 13, 2008 Go to Tools -> Settings -> Build tab, untick Create AUDIO_TS Folder and hit OK (creation of CERTIFICATE folder is linked to this option in ImgBurn 2.4.2.0) The "No Disc" message sort of gives away that the player was unable to read data from the disc and not the presence or not of the CERTIFICATE folder (I think it would say something like "Invalid Disc/Format"). What brand and type of media you're using? Do you verify your burns? If it's BD-R/BD-RE, do you have FastWrite disabled or enabled? I am waiting to get hold of a Sony S350 that plays all types of DVD. I currently have access to the Samsung 1500. I am recording onto several makes of DVD+RW's and the Samsung do not recognise them unless they are DVD ROM. I have done that and got one disc working. I then reburned a different video and it didn't recognise the disc again despite still being DVD ROM'D. I am hoping the Sony player will be easier to test with as it works with DVD+RW's I'll do a reburn using that option unticked as I prefer to use Imgburn.
nwg Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 I managed to burn a disc with just the BDMV folder and for some reason it didn't work when it worked last time. I will leave it for now until I get that Sony BD player.
DominikM Posted September 14, 2008 Author Posted September 14, 2008 Hi again... This is AVCHD correct directory structure. I have created it with HD Writer, using single sequence recorded with Panasonic camera. \AVCHDTN\ \AVCHDTN\thumbnail.tdt2 \AVCHDTN\thumbnail.tidx \BDMV\ \BDMV\index.bdmv \BDMV\MovieObject.bdmv \BDMV\BACKUP\ \BDMV\BACKUP\index.bdmv \BDMV\BACKUP\MovieObject.bdmv \BDMV\BACKUP\CLIPINF\ \BDMV\BACKUP\CLIPINF\00000.clpi \BDMV\BACKUP\PLAYLIST\ \BDMV\BACKUP\PLAYLIST\00000.mpls \BDMV\CLIPINF\ \BDMV\CLIPINF\00000.clpi \BDMV\PLAYLIST\ \BDMV\PLAYLIST\00000.mpls \BDMV\STREAM\ \BDMV\STREAM\00000.m2ts \BDMV\index.bdmv \BDMV\index.bdmv \BDMV\index.bdmv \IISVPL\ \IISVPL\00000.vpls So there is no CERTIFICATE folder. In the case of PowerDVD 8 the folder makes disc unplayable.
LIGHTNING UK! Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 Maybe it only likes the certificate folder if it's on BD media? You could test this theory using Virtual CloneDrive and adding MediaType=BDR to the .DVD file. It should then mount the ISO (with and without the CERTIFICATE folder) as a BDR disc. I'd be interested to hear if PowerDVD 8 will play the exact same content from a BD disc but not a DVD one.
nwg Posted September 22, 2008 Posted September 22, 2008 I have the Sony S350 BD player now and I can confirm that it needs the certificate folder not burned to work. However the video is stuttery but that is the fault of the Blu Ray to AVCHD software I am using. I am using the original bitrates of the Blu Ray discs and I think the AVCHD spec doesn't go that high up.
LIGHTNING UK! Posted September 22, 2008 Posted September 22, 2008 Hmm I guess I need to extend my 'Create CERTIFICATE Folder' option from a simple 'Yes / No' checkbox to an 'Ask / Yes / No' combobox. It doesn't even sound as if I can always leave it out when I know I'm burning directly to DVD media. I guess I could always include it when going direct to Blu-ray though, that should be safe enough.
Bokko Posted October 6, 2008 Posted October 6, 2008 I have the Sony S350 BD player now and I can confirm that it needs the certificate folder not burned to work. However the video is stuttery but that is the fault of the Blu Ray to AVCHD software I am using. I am using the original bitrates of the Blu Ray discs and I think the AVCHD spec doesn't go that high up. Hi NWG, I've got the same Sony BD S350 player and..... the same problems.. I want to burn a movie to a DVD+R or DVD+RW (DVD5) I've tryed to: - burn the BDMV and the CERTIFICATE folder onto the root of the disk using UDF 2.50, doesn't work..... - burn only the BDMV folder onto the root of the disk using UDF 2.50, doesn't work..... When I tryed to burn another movie, which was packed as an iso containing the BDMV and the CERTIFICATE folder, It DID work! So both ways I've burned both folders onto the root, but only the iso worked.... strange, or not?? The BD S350 is a beauty and has great quality, but sometimes I wish I still had my PS3 which just swallowed everything. Can someone help me explain how to burn a AVCHD movie for my Sony BD S350
LIGHTNING UK! Posted October 6, 2008 Posted October 6, 2008 Care to provide details about the ISO you burnt that DID work? Can you copy + paste everything from the log when you burnt that file please? Have you tried building a new disc/image based on content of the disc that does work and then seeing if that works / doesn't work?
Bokko Posted October 7, 2008 Posted October 7, 2008 Care to provide details about the ISO you burnt that DID work? Can you copy + paste everything from the log when you burnt that file please? Have you tried building a new disc/image based on content of the disc that does work and then seeing if that works / doesn't work? Sorry, but I'm a newby when it comes to blue/ray or AVCHD. Here are two logs. The first log is from the ISO which works (ImgBurn_iso_does_work.log) The second is from the BDMV and the CERTIFICATE folder which does NOT work. (ImgBurn_bdmv_certificate_does_NOT_work.log) More info about the working movie: Type.................: Movie Platform.............: PS3 Compression Format...: RAR Video Format.........: AVCHD Codec................: x264, 2pass Bitrate..............: 8000Kbps Resolution...........: 1920x1080p 1280 ImgBurn_iso_does_work.log ImgBurn_bdmv_certificate_does_NOT_work.log
LIGHTNING UK! Posted October 7, 2008 Posted October 7, 2008 Ok, what you need to do is put the disc in the drive that Nero made and ImgBurn burnt (i.e. from the top log) and then add that drive to the 'Source' box in Build mode. i.e. put the disc back in your E: drive and add 'E:\' to the source box in Build mode. Then click 'Build' to make a new ISO and burn that ISO to a new disc. That way we've got 2 discs with identical files, 1 of which you know works. So if the 2nd one doesn't it must be down to the filesystem implementation. If that's the case I'll get back to you with more instructions so I can figure out why
Bokko Posted October 8, 2008 Posted October 8, 2008 Ok, what you need to do is put the disc in the drive that Nero made and ImgBurn burnt (i.e. from the top log) and then add that drive to the 'Source' box in Build mode. i.e. put the disc back in your E: drive and add 'E:\' to the source box in Build mode. Then click 'Build' to make a new ISO and burn that ISO to a new disc. That way we've got 2 discs with identical files, 1 of which you know works. So if the 2nd one doesn't it must be down to the filesystem implementation. If that's the case I'll get back to you with more instructions so I can figure out why Sorry, but I don't understand what you mean Correct me if I'm wrong. 1) I put the working disc in my E: drive and create an image on my hard disc 2) Burn the new image to a new disc 3) Check if the new disc works
LIGHTNING UK! Posted October 8, 2008 Posted October 8, 2008 Yes, but don't use 'Read' mode to create your new image, just use the *working* disc in your E: drive as the 'Source' in 'Build' mode.
Bokko Posted October 8, 2008 Posted October 8, 2008 Yes, but don't use 'Read' mode to create your new image, just use the *working* disc in your E: drive as the 'Source' in 'Build' mode. I'll try that and keep you posted! Thanx in advance!
Recommended Posts